Random Babysitter Horror Stories (20 items)

(#16) Rogue Kid Paints the Garage While Babysitter Sleeps
After falling asleep on the couch, one sitter awoke to find the 10-year-old he was babysitting had gotten into the garage, opened a can of bright blue paint, and had painted designs on the outside of the garage door. Luckily, the kid's mom made the kid, not the babysitter, repaint the garage door.

(Source)
(#12) Dad Accidentally Shoots Babysitter

After dinner, a couple stopped home to check on their children and babysitter before heading out again. While at home, the man realized the gun he had in the house was malfunctioning. While he was trying to repair it, it fired, shooting the babysitter in the abdomen. She died later on at the hospital.
(#9) Kids Gets Flashed in Exchange for Keeping Quiet

After getting caught smoking a joint by the kid she was supposed to be looking after, a babysitter showed her boobs in exchange for a promise to not tell anyone. Guess the cat's out of the bag!
(Source)
(#6) Kids Served Peanut Butter and Glass Sandwich

After not being able to open a glass jar of peanut butter, a babysitter slammed the jar to open it. She then made peanut butter sandwiches that had tiny shards of glass in them. Mmmm... peanut butter, glass, and bloody mouths... delicious!
(Source)
(#8) Babysitter Scars Left-Handed Child

After being left with a new babysitter for the day, a child returned home and immediately asked her mother what the word "evil" means. Having never uttered the word in front of her daughter, the mother was concerned. Turns out, the babysitter had called the child "evil" for being left-handed. When the woman called the babysitter, the babysitter not only admitted to saying that, but also told the woman she needed to "fix" her daughter so she wouldn't go to hell.
(Source)
(#15) Babysitter Lets Kids Destroy Faces with Permanent Marker

A last-minute trip forced a mother to leave her children with a new babysitter. When she returned home she found her toddler and his baby sister's faces coated in permanent black marker. The sitter had instructed her son to "color" while she was making a call to her boyfriend.
(Source)